Why Many Doctors Live Paycheck to Paycheck

6

I was having a discussion with a colleague recently, and the conversation eventually  turned toward finances. He informed me that if his home refinance didn’t go through, he would have difficulty in making his house payment next month. Needless to say, this was weighing heavily on his mind, and he was visibly stressed.

I sympathized with him.

It bothered me deeply that even after finishing his training and “making it” as an attending, he was still essentially living paycheck to paycheck. I thought about it for a good while, and realized I had to dig a little deeper.

After all, how is it possible that a physician making over $250,000 a year is barely scraping by, and living in fear of missing his next mortgage payment?

Assumptions

I decided to break it down on a spreadsheet, and made a couple of safe assumptions for a physician working and living in Southern California. Here’s a quick key to what you’ll see:

●      Our example is a family of four with one working parent (the doctor)
●      Income Tax – I’ve assumed a 35% effective tax rate, but I’ll show what it would look like as a 30% or 40% effective tax rate
●      Student loans – I used the current average loan of the typical graduating medical student ($183,000), consolidated at a 10 year term, at 2.95%.
●      Mortgage – I assumed a purchase price of 1.5 million, which, unfortunately, is pretty average here in Southern California. I also assumed a 20% down payment and a standard interest rate of 4%.
●      Private school average tuition is $22,000 per year or $1833.33 per month, 2nd child is in preschool.
●      Food – According to the USDA, the average cost to feed a family of four is $1200/month. Living in California, the cost is easily almost double that.

I didn’t even include extra miscellaneous items such as home maintenance and upgrades, clothing, entertainment, etc.

The Spreadsheet

Here is the spreadsheet I designed to shed a little light on this predicament.

Living Paycheck to Paycheck

When it’s been broken down like this, it’s easy to see why the average doctor might be struggling to keep up, especially living in a place like Southern California. And how do most physicians make up the difference? They work harder and longer. Perhaps they pick up extra shifts. Unfortunately, this equates to simply working more just to support your current lifestyle, leaving precious little to be able to save or invest.

Surely, there must be a better way.

Well, I’ll come right out and say that a perfect solution doesn’t exist. However, it is my opinion that working harder or working more is not sustainable. This will only worsen the physician burnout epidemic.

I’ll never pretend to have all the answers. I just know that I am taking steps to avoid ending up in the same situation. Yes, one of the obvious answers is to reduce your expenses. That’s easy to suggest.

However, I want to focus just as much (if not more) on creating additional sources of passive income. The harsh reality is that we can only work so hard. Our time is both limited and precious, and it shouldn’t be spent working more, just to make ends meet.

If my colleague’s situation resonates with you for whatever reason, I encourage you to follow my journey. There’s always a better way. Let’s find it together.

What do you think about these expenses? Can you relate or not?

 

6 COMMENTS

  1. Some of this seems straight out of Millionaire Next Door. Can you not live in a cheaper house or send your kids to a public school?

    How does a dishwasher, cook, or a teacher survive in Southern California? Surely, other professions bringing in far less money manage to “scrape by” without having to miss mortgage payments.

  2. Is a 30% effective tax rate a reasonable estimate in California? I live in the Midwest (wife is a physician, I’m an engineer) and our effective tax rate is around 35% once you include FICA and state/local income taxes. California’s state tax rate is significantly higher than our state’s, so it seems to me that even 40% would be on the low end.

    You also didn’t include any retirement contributions in your hypothetical budget. That’s another $1,500/month just to max out your yearly pre-tax contribution.

    I think the big takeaway from this post is that a family with $250k income can’t afford a $1.5 million home and private school.

LEAVE A REPLY

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.